So today I went back and ordered a NY cheese slice and Buffalo Chicken slice...
After waiting about 10 minutes for two slices, I was thoroughly disappointed.
These are not NY style slices in taste OR size (I am from NY and am well versed in the ways of quality pizza. I also worked in a pizza shop in NY).
The cheese slice was dreadful. The quality of cheese they use is just terrible and evident after the first bite. This tastes like something an amateur made in their own kitchen.
The buffalo chicken was slightly better, but nothing to shout home about.
Both slices rang up to $5.41, which seemed acceptable until I witnessed the size and tasted the slices. Additionally the crust was terrible.
Do yourself a favor and look elsewhere.
This place is overpriced and I can't even call it mediocre.