Well you are in the middle of Amish Country so if this your first time to experience Amish cooking you could somewhat be wow'd by this restaurant I give them 2 stars for the breakfast they hands down win the best breakfast in Middlefield in terms of the full country breakfast I think they are a little over commercialized to be called authentic Amish cooking however it is an impressive venue with the Amish bakery and store inside but lacks real home style cooking.
In my opinion this is carbohydrate overload at it's best and over indulgence is the draw for many. I think it's very difficult to have quantity and quality in the same package and this is my issue with Mary Yoder's they have some how convince themselves that more is better so I agree with some of the other reviews that boxed gravies, and processed meat replaces the advertised idea the name implies. As many times as I've eaten breakfast here and a few times for lunch I have never once seen a horse and buggy tied up outside or an Amish family feasting on the fare the intent is to attract tourists and in saying that mission accomplished. I think traveling south to Holmes County around Millersburg is required to get he full Amish experience.