I am a traditional Velvet Tango Room fan. This is the only place in town that holds a candle to VTR in the custom cocktail biz.
I find the atmosphere to be a little more comfortable and less stuffy than VTR. I went after an Indians game and was severely under-dressed. I didn't feel judged. I sat at one of their comfy tables and was immediately asked what drink I would like.
I have only ever had the maple old fashioned which is one of the best drinks I have ever had in the Cleveland area. I would strongly suggest it if you're into bourbon and you go there to order that.
This place is absolutely worthy of your pricey cocktail dollar. The maple infused old fashioned will run you about 14 bucks. It is a great night cap to any one of the fantastic dining options that you have on East 4th.