First, the shop is SO DARN CUTE. It's perfect for a little coffee date or just to work on stuff you've been putting off all week.
The first time I went, I had a cupcake, their lemon blackberry I believe. Although they tasted good, the texture was a little dry and it felt like they had been sitting out all day. But still, I kept hearing great things and I came in again to try a red velvet the next time! Still dry. Definitely not worth it for the $$ they charge for just one cupcake.
Their coffee is great, and honestly I'll probably be back to try their icecream when it gets a little warmer. They've also re-done the menu since the last time I was there.
TD;DR 5/5 ambiance, 5/5 service, 2/5 cupcakes