I haven't been to the original Amelie's in NoDa so I don't have a source of comparison. I stopped in after a Sunday Brunch and got a Chai Latte. They didn't have non-fat milk, only 2% but also offered Soy milk. I opted for 2% and while the flavor was delicious the 2% milk made it a little heavy just following a meal.
I got a small tea cake which was good but not great. However, everything looked fresh. For a weekend in Uptown (which can be slower for some restaurant) I thought they were well stocked. They had pre-made sandwiches and other items to grab and go including at least 3 carafes of coffee for a quick cup.
I can see what they are trying to do with the decor but I'm not sure they gave it 100%. That said, it's still very quaint and a great alternative to the chain style coffee shops. Give them a try, I'm sure you won't be disappointed.