Great for oysters at the bar with beer or wine, but completely mediocre and overpriced for lunch or dinner (and I live across the street - I've been here many times for dinner!). Staff are friendly and knowledgeable, restaurant is clean, food is fresh. But the food is so unremarkable! One time, for lunch, I ordered a grilled tuna wrap and got canned tuna. The staff were quick to apologize and took it off my bill... but yuck! Canned tuna at a seafood restaurant?
Calamari is good, fish entrees are always fine... but for the price, I would go just about anywhere else. I don't know how else to explain this other than "uninspired". Relatively common fare, and not in a classic way. I would expect this kind of presentation to be about $10 less per plate.
Last spring/summer they had a mussels, fries, and pint of beer special on. That was delicious! I hope they do that again.