In town for my son's lacrosse tournament - I grew up on the east coast and love a good Maine lobster roll and so does my son. We made a point of visiting Lobsterman's Restaurant to check it out. The lobster chowder came in a very savory broth with lots of lobster and big chunks of potato, very tasty. The coleslaw that came with the sandwich was not over-sauced, flavorful and the cabbage was crisp. The lobster rolls were very good. A generous serving of big chunks of lightly seasoned lobster meat on a toasted bun. The bun is definitely the weak point of an overall very good experience - it could be more buttery, more toasted and of a lighter consistency, but it's just fine.
The woman who served us was extremely friendly and helpful.
We did see reviews suggesting that $17 for a lobster roll is too expensive. I don't know where those people eat a good lobster roll...in Maine, Boston and even on the west coast, a solid lobster roll is $20+, so I feel this was very reasonable for what we received. Yes, lobster rolls are a lot more expensive than your average sandwich, but this was well worth it.
We both will be back and hope that the Lobsterman's Restaurant is here when we return.