I agree with Will here. This place is what it is, and you go there for what it is. Did you follow that? Let me break it down for you.
1. The drinks are cheap. So cheap, in fact, that my NYC friend couldn't believe his eyes and was double-fisting the whole night. Oh and offering to buy everyone drinks. WIN!
2. The bartenders were friendly. Just as expected at a joint like this.
3. Pool tables. They weren't free the night we went there, but sounds like they have free pool. Perfect for a cheap beer place.
4. I don't like the smoke. I come from Ohio where it's been illegal to smoke in restaurants in Columbus since even before the laws were passed state-wide. There is an outside patio area for those who want to escape it. (it could easily be where the smokers are sent. hint hint Brookline Pub. :) )
But I do think this bar is for those Yinzers who are there for a cheap beer, a game of pool and a good time, and unfortunately that involves smoking for the majority of them. All in all, this place is cool in my book.