What more can I say other than Bob Bob Bob!
The initial review of The Punch Room (TPR) is stuck up and over priced. Then you check the other reviews and dammit you got it BUT not really. The atmosphere of TPR is so laid back but I recommend business casual but some folks show up in tshirts. Hey if you're going to pay a few bucks for cocktails might as well show up for it.
My hopes was to recreate a cocktail that I had at a speakeasy in New York but that didn't happen. Bob completely shutdown the thought but his recommendation was not close to what I wanted but the drink was well executed and strong so I was content. If I'm going to pay for a drink it better be worth it and it was so plus plus for Bob. Bob explained the drink and its contents which added to the experience.
Overall, come for the experience but be open for suggestions. The staff is super sweet and nice. I've read reviews of bad service but we had the greatest service from start to finish.
Enjoy folks and try the Bitter Butter, was my fav of the night.