I went here for my brothers birthday in summer 2012, I have the braised beef rib on mashed potatoes with au jus.
The atmosphere and presentation are A+. Intimate lighting, nicely styled, and good colors. The plate presentations on the food from what I saw are pretty good all around.
I found the food portions to be all over the place, with the pasta my father ordered to be quite large compared to my beef rib, vs the fish dish my mother ordered. The food definitely has thought and care put into it. I found it to be a little on the salty side, but I wouldn't necessarily assume this is the same for all the dishes as I only tried the beef rib.
All that being said, If I was going for a date in the area, I would consider Chatterpaul's as one of my options.