You know that scene in When Harry Met Sally where Meg Ryan fakes an orgasm in Katz's? Well, that's the reason why Tootie's only has one table. One bite and your eyes will roll into the back of your head and you'll be making sounds you've never made in your life. These sandwiches are really *THAT* good.
Try the Nicky T. - it's the best of both worlds with both chicken and beef. You'll wish you'd ordered at least two, so you may as well just give in.
Bonus: Small, family-run business, owned by a genuinely nice guy.