I'm pretty happy with Giant Rustic Pizza. There aren't too many NY style pizza joints in the Arcadia area, at least not too many good ones in my opinion. I usually will travel to N. Scottsdale to Ray's if I'm craving pizza like home. That being said I thought Giant Rustic Pizza was pretty good, not quite the same as NY but good enough for me to return. My husband and I wanted a cheat meal and both checked out the menu. I wanted to try the Red White & Green which is a white pizza and my husband really wanted a more traditional style with sauce. I asked if they could do half & half and they said "yes." We both got what we wanted, which is awesome. We also ordered the Italian salad which was somewhat like an antipasto with lettuce, the portion size was very generous. Both types of pizza were very flavorful, the white pizza had some nice ricotta on it and the red pizza had great sauce. I can't comment too much on the ambiance as we got our order to-go, but the staff was very nice and our order was fast. I will definitely return!