I kept it simple on my 1st visit and ordered a pepperoni slice with a side of ranch and a vanilla coke. I'm glad I only ordered 1 slice because the slices are huge! They sell 14" slices and 28" pies. I was full before I even finished my slice. Other sauces they offer for dipping are marinara and garlic sauce.
They have monthly specials, so that will keep me coming back to try all the delicious combinations they come up with.
If after eating your pizza you are craving something sweet, you can grab a King of Pops Popsicle to curb your sweet tooth.
Benny's does not deliver, but they are open late night 7 days a week.