I wanted to love this place, I really did. Considering it's about 20 minutes from Newmarket, it was quite a drive. But I had to try it out.
I ordered a medium pizza. It's a large medium, probably outmeasures most restaurants, so already you get your money's worth. I got pepperoni, sausage and peppers. Peppers are cut in cubes, pepperoni is fine, but the sausage is flavourless and placed over the pizza in giant chunks, as opposed to finely cut and placed more frequently.
The dough is good and chewy, but the sauce... you can tell it's homemade and pretty authentic. Very tomato paste tasting. I won't lie I wish there were some more herbs or spices.
Will I go back? If I'm in the area. Overall, the hype around this restaurant didn't really meet expectation. But it's an independent business and I'll always chose to support them over chain restaurants.