There's alot to like about Pizza Peel. The lunch special is a buffet of pizza, drink, and a salad. The toppings and crust are both flavorful, and their salads are surprisingly great too. I'm all for Dominoes or Papa Johns as much as the next guy, but Pizza Peel is where I'd go for a great pie.
They have dozens of beers on tap, and a nice variety of other dishes. I haven't tried anything but the pizza buffet, but based on that experience, I'd easily go back for dinner.
The only knock I have against them is their prices. Everything seems a little high, and $20 for a large pizza is a tough pill to swallow. But the quality is good, and the staff is friendly too.