I decided to give Pomo another shot. I ended up at the same high table that overlooks the kitchen. For whatever reason, this spot seems to be unpopular but I like it because it keeps me warm AND I can see what's going on with my food!
My friend and I shared the Mista salad and the Pomo pizza. I was much more pleased this time with the food we ordered! The sausage on the Pomo pizza was delicious and the Mista salad was larger and more filling than we expected. It's also fun to get all of the little freebies. They brought out bread and oil, the fried strips of dough with powdered sugar (again), limoncello (again), and then this sweet cake. It felt like the longer we sat there, the more food they put in front of us! Service is very attentive and I never felt that we had to wait long for anything. Also, I'm assuming the man who gives out the limoncello shots is the owner and it's fun to see him around.
The pizza is still not my favorite in the valley (hence the 4 stars) but I can definitely say that it's a solid place to go and it's a nice option in the pizza rotation.