I'd probably give my rating a 3.5 if I could.
I visited the shop for my first time on National Pizza Day... Tempted by the ads I was seeing on Facebook for pizza pot pie. I was a little off put when looking at some of the dessert pies in the show cases because they looked a little old. I had contemplated getting one of the chocolate dipped strawberry pies for Valentines, but the strawberries and raspberries on it looked very old. I'm not sure if that was because it was just a show pie to show what it looks like vs the actual pie one would get.
I was excited for dinner and my pizza pot pies. I got them frozen and followed the directions to bake them. While they were fairly good, all 3 of us who ate one agreed that they were very soupy inside. There was a lot of liquid and it was more eating pizza soup. I did enjoy the crust though, but was disappointed it didn't line the whole pie tin.
I might try them again at some point, but the pies are very pricey and I'm not sure the quality is something I can't get elsewhere at lower cost.