I also am surprised at some of the bad reviews, they must have been having an off night on those nights! I went with a group after work and felt the atmosphere was perfect, the food was ridiculously good (had half portions of both the lobster ravioli and sacchetti al tartufo), the wine was delicious and the service was reasonable. I am almost afraid to go back because I loved it so much and am worried it won't live up to those expectations again after reading some of the other reviews... but I have a reservation for this Friday so I'll update my review then if needed!