My husband and I frequent Rusty's several times per month and love it. Their menu is simple - sandwiches, burgers, soups/salads, fries - but the quality is consistenly good. I love their reubens, and their fries are always hot, crispy and plentiful. Other great picks - BLT, cheeseburger, chicken salad, bratwurst.
I love Rusty's and always recommend it to my family and friends if we're looking for a simple place to have a lunch or small dinner. My dad discovered it several years ago while my mother and I were shopping for my wedding dress and I'm so glad he did!!