2.5 stars.
My husband and I got an order of gelato each: chocolate and salty peanut butter. For a small cup it was about $4.50 so we expected it to be good. We rate our treats 2.5 out of 5 - didn't enjoy it and I threw out half of mine.
Really, for the price it should be amazing or the sizes should be increased. I don't get the hype...they had posted recommendations from different magazines in the window.