I've lived in the same neighborhood as Caffe Roma for years. I dined here the week I moved into my new house in 2008 and really had no desire to return, despite its convenient location.
I recently made a second visit, totally hoping that they've improved. But nope!
I just don't get it - the penne arrabiata I ordered was basically penne with Ragu for about $10. My date ordered pasta olio e aglio (normally my favorite dish to order at any Italian restaurant), and he was underwhelmed as well.
I should have consulted Yelp reviews first... Maybe in five or six years when I venture back against my will, I'll try the pizza.
Also, the rumors of the employees not getting tipped out - that is pretty disturbing.