I went for brunch so this review is just based on that, I have no opinion on drinks and other meals.
For a brunch that seems like love was made into the dishes, Merchant Madison does a great job.
A friend and I both got the omelette made with oyster mushrooms and sauteed onions with potatoes and a side salad. I am not giving five starts because the salad contained a ton of frieze, when it should have had more spring lettuce. Frieze is not a good base lettuce because it is so prickly. The potatoes were AMAZING, perfect amount. The omelet was delicious too but was also coated in oil (so it would come out of the pan perfectly?), which I know is not necessary, just a gross shortcut. I just ignored that unneeded added calories.
Coffee was great. Price was great too for quality and size.