Fancy Nails has quickly moved to the top of my Madison manicure list. They offer shellac (a.k.a. gel or acrylic) manicures, which have lasted 2-3 weeks without chipping or peeling - and I'm extremely hard on my nails/hands in general.
The shellac manicures are approximately $10 more expensive than a typical manicure, but completely worth it for the amount of time and quality of the manicure.
Fancy Nails takes walk-ins as well as appointments, and while I typically call ahead, I've also walked in and never waited more than 20 minutes to be seated. The manicures and pedicures I've had have been thorough and relaxing, regardless of which technician I'm seeing.
There are other locations in Madison that will pamper you during your manicure, so if you're looking for a salon whose staff will cater to you, Fancy Nails is probably not the place for you. However, my experience with the manicure itself and the results has hands down been best with Fancy Nails. So if you're looking for a high-quality manicure or pedicure, along with speedy and cost-effective service, Fancy Nails is your place.