I'd give this 3.5.
I'm glad to see I'm not the only one who commented about the hot sauce! I think its colour (thousand-island orange) is misleadingly creamy because I didn't do a mini-taste test first before pouring a bit on my arepa and my mouth turned into the centre of the SUN for a good five minutes. Serves me right!
This place is really cute, good atmosphere, especially in summer months.
Anyway, to the food: The arepa flatbread is really tasty, like a cornbread English muffin. I got the veggie arepa, which had so many black beans I couldn't finish them all, but the plantain and avocado were really tasty.
Boyfrond got the cod, which he wasn't too impressed with--I guess the fish was pretty dry. Everything was served, as others have mentioned, with three different sauces, service was decent as it can be when it's hopping busy.
I'd definitely give this place another shot--it's a perfect go-to for a casual bite on queen west.