I got a pretty deep dent at the corner of my rear bumper. Both Zimbrick and Gate's Auto in town told me I had to replace my bumper and paint the whole thing (~$900).
I found out this store from Ads; they specialize specifically in small cosmetic defect repair. They could do the job within a day and I paid ~$335. Oh, they also said they can touch up some chipped spots on the hoods for only an additional $10. When i got the car back, I totally couldn't tell the history.
The staff is also very courteous. They've got pix on their website.