The Good:
- beautiful space, tastefully renovated and decorated
- friendly staff
- delicious pizza crust
The Not So Good:
- You can't get appetizers (salads etc) unless you opt for the $25 prix fixe option (but I don't want dessert!!!)
- Pizza was good, not great - crust was excellent, but I ordered a funghi pizza and the mushrooms looked like they came straight out of a can
- while our server was friendly, he wasn't the most attentive
- $32 with tax and tip for a pizza + tiny appetizer and dessert I didn't really want/need?
Overall I'd give it another shot, but if you're gonna charge those kinds of prices it'll take a bit more to keep me coming back.
Also, I should add that the 80's pop tunes blaring from the stereo kinda detracted from the experience - was totally out of place.
A welcome addition to the neighbourhood, hopefully they can tweak the menu/experience a bit.