Although I loved the decor, I wasn't terribly impressed with the food. My boyfriend and I had wandered over to Schenley Plaza to get a relatively cheap lunch at the Chinese stand, but we found it was still closed for the season. So we decided to give The Porch a try.
We each had a pizza - I had the margherita pizza and he had the bolognese. The flavor was good but they were overcooked and oily. The pieces literally fell apart as we tried to pick them up off of the cookie sheet. We had to flag our waitress down anytime we needed something (i.e. drink refills, the check) because she paid no attention at all to the tables. When we asked for a to go box she brought us one small box that we had to stuff the leftovers in, which left us with a box stuffed with deformed, mushy pizza.
I would be satisfied with The Porch if it were at the right price - for what we got, it was definitely not worth it.