More of a 3.5 star place for me. I had a lunch combo that gets you 2 special rolls for $25. I chose rainbow and caterpillar. They were okay. Ingredients were fresh enough but not impressively so. The portion was not stingy but not very generous either - the roll could've used more avocado. I know a bunch of sushi places elsewhere in the states that serve much better dishes for the same price, but perhaps if you're looking for a sushi place within Madison this place is acceptable.