My husband and I tried this place on New Year's Eve, with no reservations, nonetheless. We originally headed to a chain but decided not to wait the 1 hour and 45 minute wait time. I had read a review in a local paper that day so we decided to give it a try.
The place is in a little strip mall and is a little hard to find. The staff was pleasant and apologized for not being able to get us in right away (we waited about 5-7 minutes). The ambiance isn't anything great and the tables were pretty close together. (Hence the 4 starts not 5).
But let me tell you about the food.... mmmmmm..... I'll preface by saying I'm Italian. And Italian food is by far my favorite. I ordered the lasagna. The sauce was magnificent. I could have eaten an entire additional portion, it was that good. My husband had some type of penne dish in a wine sauce. Equally as good. The house wine was also very good.
But let me tell you about the dessert. OMG. I have never been a huge tiramisu fan but read that it was good so we tried it. I have been dreaming about it ever since. I could eat a 9x13 pan for breakfast- every day it was that good. A little too much cocoa on top, but otherwise heavenly. We also had the cheesecake, which was also amazing.
If you are looking for great food, but maybe not a romantic atmosphere, you have to try this place.