I had high expectations for this place as its a Pittsburgh legend as far as restaurants go. I wans't necessarily let down, but I can't see what all the type was about.
The beer was good. We got one German style beer and one American style brew with 3 types of hops. Both were great. We split the tuna appetizer (4 stars) and the black bean soup with cilantro sour cream (4 stars) and a salmon salad (4 stars).
So why three stars? Over priced for what you get - luckily we were not too hungry our we would have left craving more. Also, the service was so so at best and the food took more time than usual. I didn't really like the environment of the outdoor seating either.
Overall, I would return but have mixed feelings about the reputation this place has been able to build for itself.