I agree that the decor makes you feel like you're not in Arizona. It made me feel like I was in New York. In 1988. The only thing missing were some Keith Haring posters.
It's got a kind of (dated) too-cool-for-it's-own-good vibe that tends to make me hostile. The $14 martinis (!) didn't decrease my antipathy, nor did the tiniest four-top that I've ever seen, or at least been expected to dine at. The waiter literally had to remove everything from our table so four dinner plates would fit.
However, the food was much better than I expected. I ordered the grilled cheese sandwich as several people here have suggested and it was excellent. My wife had a salad that was delicious and plentiful.
Service was friendly and charming, if a bit inept.
Bottom line, nice spot with good people watching (and the only restaurant on the Scottsdale Mall that had any customers at all on the night we were there). Cheap food and extremely expensive drinks.