Last year I ordered Eli's cheesecake for my husband's birthday. He appreciated the thought but was like, "meh". This year, I ordered from Just a Bite (on one day's notice) and my husband LOVED it.
The cake came right to my door. They communicated the order and delivery arrangements efficiently. When they had to change the delivery time, they were professional and also gave me a generous deal on the cake. But more than anything it was like talking to a long time, friendly neighbor. Made my day.