I've never been here without a groupon so I can't really comment on any price related matters.
My wife and I have a couple sandwiches we like, with the yard bird being out current favorite. It has bacon, cheese, and apple on a turkey sandwich. Since they seem to love to do groupons we have been here five or six times recently and their quality is consistant.
The macaroni salad is a little dry, but the pickles are indeed spicy.
Probably not a must visit, but I'll be keeping an eye out for more coups and will return with those.