Take a number and be prepared to wait and wait and wait some more!
So after a 45 min. wait I was hoping for amazing cannoli's and for the price we paid, let's just say I was looking for Buddy himself, because I wouldn't have wanted anyone else to have made them! However I wound up paying $3.50 per cannoli for a giant disappoint and the pleasure of waiting 45 min. in a small crowded bakery along with a ton of other people who were all crowded in on top of each other so we could try to hear our numbers being called because if you missed your number they weren't going to call it again! And it wasn't like you could make your selection or look at the case while you were waiting because the people were so crowded into the bakery like sardines that they were all up on the case blocking it from view from everyone. When your number was called you had to push your way through just to look at the case to see what they even had, but the selection was pretty dismal anyway so it really didn't matter. Your choices were cookies, mini cheese cakes, cannoli's, chocolate covered strawberries or lobster tails. For being such a well known bakery the selection was awful.
As for the Carlos Bakery amazing cannoli recipe, they just average and the cookies were just cookies. I will say that the Lobster Tail was pretty good though, but I would never wait in that crazy line for another one.