What I would do for a Gotham bagel on a hungover Saturday morning right now...
This was a staple for most people who came to UW-Madison from out of state. While it is kind of pricey, it is worth every penny! The bagels are fantastic. My favorite sandwich is the Eggplant Parm special. My friends love the long-guy land. A regular bagel and cream cheese also cannot be beat.
The service is so/so. The lines are long, and I have definitely had some off experiences, but I would go back in a heartbeat.