The current star rating of 3.5 stars is incredibly accurate of Mineo's. I'm going to be unpopular and round up to 4 stars because I think Mineo's is a more unique pizza than other places in Pittsburgh. You're going to be indifferent or love it. I'm confused about my emotions, clearly.
Disclaimer: I did not order a pie here, only two slices.
Mineo's crust is unique. It's thin but not like cheap Pizza Hut burnt-to-a-crisp-thin pizza. It's almost like the dough doesn't rise the whole way or something, but it worked for me. The sauce was ok, not too special. But I love cheese, and this pizza was swimming in cheese. It was pretty fast for my two slices to come out, and at $1.70/slice, not terribly priced.
I actually had really friendly service while I was there so I'm not sure about those complaints. The tables were a little dirty and some weirdos were sitting inside. Not pizza items were super slow, but it's not a huge kitchen. I wasn't totally shocked by that. I would come back here for a few slices on a laid-back night.
Cash Only