Good, but not great. I went here after my friends and I saw this pizza shop had received national attention on clevescene.com. We ordered the master Popeye and master deluxe pizzas. They were okay, but not worthy of national recognition, from our opinions. It could have been that we had anticipated this pizza to be so amazing, and then it was sort of a letdown. We stayed there to eat. There was a large party in the dining area. One of the party members was throwing spitballs, that I had been hit by accidentally. When I looked up to see what happened, he started talking about how I was staring at him, pretty loudly. This knocked the experience down another star for me. I know this place has multiple locations, so maybe the pizza and experience could have been better a different location. I know I won't be going back.