I think my expectations were too high. I was thinking Nopa in SF (nopasf.com). You can decide for yourself what I got below.
Some low points:
*The greeting. I don't expect a happy cheerleader but I do expect eye contact and an attempt at a smile or welcoming nature. I saw this lacking with folks who arrived after we did.
*Too experimental. I was very excited when reviewing the menu. The simple labels and titles are great. But, upon arrival of the dishes, I was overwhelmed. For a person who LOVES to experiment with new food and gives everything a try, this is a first. If you stumble upon this place while looking for the Old Fashioned, keep looking.
High Points:
*Our waitress was great. Efficient, friendly, knowledgeable. Quite nice in Madison.
*The atmosphere is awesome. Very good for both a small group or an intimate dinner.
*The cocktail was delicious.
I will give it another try as I want to check out the bar. Hopefully that will raise the score.