More of a 4 1/2! Been here a few times and always excellent. Service, even in the bar. is second to none. Had the Indian spiced short rib and it's to die for. So aromatic you can't believe it. The carrots as a side are nice as well. They give you so many snacks in the lounge area of the bar - popcorn, olives, miso peas, nuts, small bready pastries and tiny dessert assortment after dinner. Awesome! Also had the butter lettuce salad and it was very good. The pretzel and five grain breads were amazing. Had their version of an old fashioned and it was good but I have had better. A Ketel One with three olives was tasty and a 20 year tawny to finish up the meal. Really enjoyed it. Will go back.