Maybe 3 stars, but I'm knocking one off for the poor service.
My wife and I went here on a Saturday night around 10pm for drinks and snacks.
I got a local IPA and she got a rum and coke. My beer was overly-bitter and lacked any sweetness or brightness that a good IPA usually has. The rum and coke was balanced but nothing to write home about.
Our food was the worst part: we got a mixed plate of salsa, sausage, and olives as well as the grilled cheese. It literally tasted like they found a handful of random things at a convenience store, threw them on a plate, and charged us $10. The grilled cheese was the least exciting thing I've tasted since the pretzels I was served on my flight here.
The crowd is pretty hip, mostly white men in their 30s.
Our server never gave us water which we explicitly asked for and then told me to hold on when I asked for the bill so she could talk to her co-worker.
The whole experience was pretty forgettable, though the ostrich heads really are awesome.