The cocktails at Butcher and the Rye are five stars for sure. Great place to grab some drinks after work! I tried the B3 Fizz, a strong but balanced gin and beet juice concoction. I also tried the punch of the day - I don't remember what was in it, but it was really good. It had spices like cinnamon and just the right sweetness. I've been here before, also for cocktails only, and everything we tried was good.
As for food, I haven't had a chance to sit down for a proper meal. I did try the gnocchi which was a daily special. It wasn't too memorable, so I'd like to come back and try the regular menu, hence the four stars for now. Service at the bar counter was good - waters were kept full and the bartender checked in on how the drinks were.