Ok. I have to say that at first sight, I was not excited that I couldn't "make" my own mix-ins. I really was hoping to pick my ice cream flavor and add my mix-ins. This is more of a traditional ice cream store model.
However, after scanning the flavors - and realizing it was hot outside and I went there because of this anyway - I decided to buy a pint and take it home to try it out.
First - a great option is you can choose two and do a "half and half" pint. This is great to try flavors, and not only that, you get two flavors in one pint! So I chose the Reese's peanut butter and the Chocolate Overload (chocolate base ice cream with fudge brownies, chocolate crunch and fudge).
Holy cow! I was impressed by both. The peanut butter was extremely flavorful and the ice cream rich. The Chocolate Overload - the chocolate flavor was intense, the brownies were soft and the chocolate crunch was a pleasant surprise as opposed to chocolate chips - more like a crunch bar. All delicious.
The next time I tried the mint variety with Girl Scout thin mints in it. While this was still delicious - I have to say I liked the other two better. Felt like the mint could be a little stronger - or even better, more natural mint. Either way, not a bad option as well.
I would definitely go back here. So far, I have not been disappointed!