Hands down my favorite pizzeria in Madison, probably the country. The ambiance is so nice and they do a great job at making you feel comfortable and not too close to the other tables. The pizza is amazing, I can't even say my favorite because it changes every time I go, which is at least every other week.
Not only are the pizzas great, but so are the apps. Burrata, octopus, scallops, are just a few examples that change all the time. And you cannot go wrong with any of them.
If you have the time (since there's usually a wait), you definitely should check this out! Even if you have to wait, you can head over to gibs next door for a drink and they'll call you over when a table is available.