Updated: Went there again a few times and realized that food is a hit or miss and service can be patchy at times. A decent option if you're in the area, but won't recommend you to drive there to eat.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
We love Cafe Diplomatico. We've been there a few times. The service has always been great and so is their pizza.
Pizza - Thin crust. Decent amount of cheese and toppings. Well done but never burnt. If you're looking for NY style or Chicago style pizza this place is not for you.
Pasta - It is usually done well, not overcooked like at many other places. The sauce however depends on your liking. Some people find it bland some okay. The quantity is huge.
Mains - We like their whole grilled Rainbow Trout. It comes with Pasta or Salad. Good sized portion.
Coffee - is meh. We expected more as its a famous cafe.
Didn't try the desserts as we usually either have churros at Pancho's or Tiramisu/Canoli at Riviera bakery or Ice cream at Sicilian Ice creams after.