The most disappointing part about Allegheny Sandwich Shoppe is that it had so much potential. We went early Saturday before a Pitt game and ordered breakfast. They weren't very busy, but the food still took 40 minutes. Then my wife's eggs, which she asked for extra well so there was no runny yolk, came out barely cooked at all. We had to send them back, and after another 15 minutes they came back out, almost just as bad. In addition, she had asked for toast dry and extra toasted. The first time it came as bread, not even toasted. The second time it came buttered. The third time, it came barely toasted again, but at this point we just wanted to leave. My omelet could have been good... but I ate it cold as I waited for my wife's food. It didn't make matters any better than the waitress rolled her eyes at us when we sent the food back. I highly doubt we will be back.