I have to bust out the four stars for this place. There comes a time when a trendy niche spot become too trendy. At lunch you'll see old couples, bankers, and punk kids sitting down at the same place. Its almost surreal, but at night it'd mainly very smoke filled.
After moving from Vegas four years ago, I'm glad i found this place to quail my In-n-Out Burger obsessions. Their fries are often overly oily and if you get their chicken fingers which are really good, they let them drip dry onto your fries. So, I'd highly recommend trying their brunswick stew if a 3000 calorie meal isnt your thing. Also check out the Penguin off hours unless you like to wait in line or eat in a heavily smoked filled room during dinner time.
I haven't been brave enough to follow Elvis' coronary desires with the fried peanut butter and banana sandwiches, but any places that has that on the menu is just plain cool. Bring some spare change as well and play some old western tunese on the jukebox.