I visited as a solo customer around 7 pm and it was quite busy. Here are the pros and cons.
Pros:
This is a nice new venue, small bar with a couple of TVs, nice decore and many seating options including a nice terrace.
There is a lovely selection of beers.
Con:
The service is poor. A classic example of under trained, poorly managed young adults trying to do their best but not knowing what to do. Well cleaned tables by the bus staff but the floor covered with dropped food. Infrequent check ups from wait staff.
My order took close to 40 minutes and not one visit or explanation.
I suspect the ratio of seats in the dining room is bigger that the kitchen can accommodate.
The pizza is a step up from Pizza Hut and Papa Johns but just barely. The toppings are ample but the crust is soulless. I asked my server if the crust was leavened with yeast and got "I don't know but we have gluten free...". I suspect that the dough is a baking powder crust.
There are better options in Madison and it is worth the travel time to avoid Sugar River.