Gray House Pies is a real Cleveland gem! I met them initially at the Waterloo Arts Festival and the North Union Farmer's Market. After enjoying a number of their pies (the Sunshine Moonshine, Drunk Cherry, and Key Lime are easy favorites!) we chose Gray House to supply the dessert for our wedding.
Gray House's homemade pies are what you would make at home - from-scratch ingredients! For the key lime pie, they make their own graham crackers for the crust!
You might miss Gray House's nondescript location in a strip mall in Westlake, but it's worth looking for! When you pop into the shop, they have additional goodies du jour (scones, short bread, etc.) that are a must-try!
Our wedding was a small affair (35 people) and the 10 pies we ordered we nearly all eaten. Afterward, the pie was one of the things people most raved about! Thank you to Gray House Pies for a great experience - on our wedding day and beyond!