Studio 21 should be your first, last and only choice for tattoos. They've done 4 of my 5, and I wish it was 5 of 5. The place is clean and professional, with the right amount of eclectic, artistic coziness.
The family that owns it is charming and dedicated to finding the best artists. My artist is Austin who is professional, friendly, wicked talented and accommodating, since I can be fidgety and am always cold. He does lovely faces (two of my pieces have faces), along with subtle light/shadows and obsessive detailing, which is why I will never leave him.
They also organize art shows and food truck battles for charitable causes. Ink + burgers + rum = HIGH FIVE.