For the price, I can't complain. $5 for a hot dog with as many toppings as your heart desires, then $2.50 more for tater tots is tough to beat. The beer selection has everything from the cheapest of the cheap to microbrews.
As for the atmosphere, it's a little tough to know when a show or anything is going on, but there's a chalkboard up front that spells everything out. That, and they always run an ad in Cleveland Scene, which is everywhere. The service can get slow when the bar gets busy, but that's nothing outlandish at all.
I wouldn't say it's an exclusively hipster place, though, and I don't think it would ever go that direction. The whole restaurant is about having fun.